American Movie (1999) [4K UHD Review]

American Movie, the 1999 documentary directed by Chris Smith, has carved out a unique place in cult movie history. Chronicling the journey of aspiring filmmaker Mark Borchardt as he works to complete his short horror film, Coven, this documentary captures the spirit of low-budget, passion-driven filmmaking. Now available in 4K UHD, American Movie looks better than ever, preserving every candid, cringe-worthy, and inspiring moment in stunning detail. This release is a testament to the raw dedication it takes to pursue creative dreams against all odds.

With the 4K restoration, the film gains new life, and fans can revisit Mark’s relentless quest with a crispness that enhances every candid frame. For both those who have already fallen in love with its charm and newcomers interested in the world of independent filmmaking, this release serves as an essential addition to any cult cinema collection.

Discover the magic of mispronouncing Coven

At its core, American Movie is a documentary about the American Dream, albeit through an unconventional lens. It follows Mark Borchardt, a scrappy independent filmmaker from Milwaukee, as he attempts to finish his low-budget horror short, Coven. Mark’s vision is ambitious, but he’s facing a mountain of obstacles—limited finances, unreliable friends, and family tension. Yet, despite all these setbacks, Mark’s unrelenting passion for filmmaking pushes him forward.

The documentary captures the stark reality of indie filmmaking. Unlike polished Hollywood productions, American Movie takes us to Mark’s cluttered kitchen table, suburban lawns used as impromptu shooting locations, and late-night editing sessions that extend into the early morning. This is filmmaking stripped of glamour—featuring friends and family who serve as cast, crew, and sometimes even financiers.

There’s a poignancy to the setting as well. Milwaukee, with its suburban neighborhoods and local bars, isn’t what most people envision when they think of moviemaking, but that’s what makes American Movie so special. It’s not about where you are; it’s about what you do with what you have. Mark’s journey to make Coven feels both hyper-specific to his environment and universally relatable to anyone who’s ever had a dream that seemed out of reach.

Meet the people of American Movie

Mark Borchardt

Mark Borchardt is the heart and soul of American Movie. He’s an eternal optimist, filled with big dreams and an unshakable desire to create, even when his resources are practically nonexistent. Mark’s personality drives the film—his passion, his frustrations, his unyielding determination. There’s a tragicomic element to Mark; his enthusiasm is so pure, but the reality of his life is often far from glamorous. His efforts to get Coven finished—juggling responsibilities, working menial jobs, and corralling friends to help—paint a vivid picture of the struggle of low-budget filmmaking.

Mark’s charisma is infectious. He’s the kind of person who will push on despite every obstacle, and that kind of relentless drive is inspiring, even when the odds are clearly stacked against him. Whether he’s trying to convince his elderly uncle to finance the film or rallying his buddies for another chaotic day of shooting, Mark’s journey embodies the true spirit of independent cinema.

Mike Schank

Mike Schank, Mark’s best friend, is the quiet but endearing sidekick of the story. Mike is almost the complete opposite of Mark—soft-spoken, introspective, and seemingly happy to follow wherever Mark’s chaotic energy takes him. Mike’s loyalty to Mark and his unwavering support, whether as an extra pair of hands on set or simply as moral support, is heartwarming. His deadpan humor and gentle demeanor provide a perfect counterbalance to Mark’s manic energy.

Mike’s presence in the film is essential—he grounds the narrative in moments of calm amidst Mark’s frenetic quest. He’s also responsible for some of the documentary’s most genuine, funny, and touching moments. His guitar strumming, impromptu wisdom, and open-hearted nature help humanize the documentary, offering an intimate portrayal of friendship forged in the fires of creative struggle.

Uncle Bill

Another key figure is Uncle Bill, Mark’s elderly uncle, who reluctantly agrees to help finance Coven. Uncle Bill’s contributions—both financial and otherwise—are vital to Mark’s efforts, but it’s clear he doesn’t entirely understand or believe in Mark’s vision. Bill’s gruffness and skeptical attitude contrast with Mark’s enthusiasm, and their interactions are often both touching and painfully funny. Uncle Bill represents the practicality that Mark seems to lack, adding yet another layer of tension and humor to the story.

Chris Smith is so earnest with American Movie

Chris Smith directs American Movie with a keen sense of empathy and humor. Rather than mock Mark’s seemingly futile efforts, Smith’s approach is respectful, allowing the audience to laugh with Mark rather than at him. The documentary’s observational style gives it an authenticity that makes you feel as though you’re right there in the trenches with Mark and his crew. It’s a fly-on-the-wall experience that captures both the absurdities and the beauty of passionate creative work.

The cinematography reflects the low-budget, DIY nature of Mark’s filmmaking process. The handheld camera work and on-the-ground perspective create a sense of intimacy and immediacy, drawing the viewer into Mark’s world. From the cramped living spaces where Mark edits footage to the freezing Wisconsin locations where he shoots his horror scenes, the visual style reinforces the raw, unfiltered nature of the journey.

The 4K UHD Release: What to expect?

The 4K UHD release of American Movie breathes new life into this cult classic. While the documentary was originally shot on a modest budget, the 4K transfer enhances every detail, preserving the gritty aesthetic while adding clarity that makes the experience feel more immersive.

Video Quality

The 4K transfer does an impressive job of preserving the raw look of the original footage. It’s not glossy or overly polished, which works perfectly given the subject matter. Instead, the UHD presentation brings out the richness of detail in Mark’s makeshift sets, the texture of the Midwest winter, and the imperfections that give the film its authenticity. The increased resolution allows viewers to catch subtle facial expressions and small details that might have been lost in earlier formats, adding a deeper layer of connection to the characters and their environment.

Audio Quality

The DTS-HD Master Audio brings clarity to the dialogue, which is key given the film’s focus on conversations and personal interactions. The audio mix ensures that every conversation—whether it’s Mark hyping up his crew or Uncle Bill’s dry commentary—comes through clearly. The background noises of Mark’s bustling household and the on-location shoots are well-preserved, enhancing the sense of immersion in his chaotic world.

Special Features

The 4K UHD release also includes several special features that offer fans a deeper dive into the making of the documentary and its legacy:

• Audio Commentary by Chris Smith and Mark Borchardt: This commentary provides a fascinating look into the making of American Movie, with Mark and Chris sharing stories and reflecting on the experience of documenting such a unique journey.
• Deleted Scenes: The collection of deleted scenes offers additional glimpses into Mark’s creative process and more moments of candid interaction between Mark, Mike, and Uncle Bill. These scenes are a great addition for those who want more insight into the behind-the-scenes struggles.
• Coven short fim: Ever wonder how Coven turned out? Well, wonder no further and watch the movie. Also, it’s CUH-VEN. Learn it, love it.
• Theatrical trailer: A look at the trailer everyone first saw in the Spring of 1999.

Movie Making in Milwaukee

American Movie is as much about dreams and determination as it is about filmmaking. It’s a story of resilience—about trying, failing, and trying again, regardless of the obstacles. Mark Borchardt’s journey is relatable not because he’s an underdog, but because he’s unapologetically himself, pursuing his passion even when it seems impractical or impossible. It’s a reminder that creative pursuits often come with setbacks, but the pursuit itself can be a source of meaning and fulfillment.

The film also explores the theme of friendship. Mark’s relationship with Mike Schank is the emotional core of the documentary, showcasing the kind of unwavering support that makes even the most impossible dreams seem achievable. Their friendship is depicted with honesty and humor, showing that the people who stand by us—especially when the chips are down—are as crucial to our success as any amount of talent or ambition.

The cultural impact of American Movie is undeniable. It has become a symbol of independent, DIY filmmaking—a cult classic that speaks to anyone who has ever tried to create something against all odds. Mark Borchardt’s story resonates because it’s about more than just making a movie; it’s about refusing to give up on your dreams, no matter how outlandish they may seem to others. The documentary captures the essence of the underdog spirit and has inspired countless viewers to pick up a camera, write that script, or simply keep going in the face of adversity.

Final Thoughts on the 4K UHD Release

The 4K UHD release of American Movie is a must-have for fans of the documentary and anyone interested in the world of independent film. The video and audio upgrades enhance the viewing experience without losing the raw, authentic feel that made the original so special. The special features provide valuable insights into the making of the documentary, adding depth to an already compelling story.

American Movie remains a testament to the passion and persistence required to create art. Mark Borchardt’s journey is both hilarious and heartbreaking, filled with moments of triumph and failure that are captured with unflinching honesty. The 4K UHD release honors the legacy of this cult classic, ensuring that its impact continues to inspire future generations of dreamers and creators. Whether you’re a longtime fan or discovering it for the first time, this release is the best way to experience Mark’s relentless pursuit of his cinematic dream.

American Movie is now available on 4K UHD at MovieZyng and other outlets

95

Buy it from our well wishers

MovieZyng